1 //
2 // Automated Testing Framework (atf)
3 //
4 // Copyright (c) 2007 The NetBSD Foundation, Inc.
5 // All rights reserved.
6 //
7 // Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without
8 // modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions
9 // are met:
10 // 1. Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright
11 // notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer.
12 // 2. Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright
13 // notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer in the
14 // documentation and/or other materials provided with the distribution.
15 //
16 // THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED BY THE NETBSD FOUNDATION, INC. AND
17 // CONTRIBUTORS ``AS IS'' AND ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES,
18 // INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF
19 // MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE ARE DISCLAIMED.
20 // IN NO EVENT SHALL THE FOUNDATION OR CONTRIBUTORS BE LIABLE FOR ANY
21 // DIRECT, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, EXEMPLARY, OR CONSEQUENTIAL
22 // DAMAGES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, PROCUREMENT OF SUBSTITUTE
23 // GOODS OR SERVICES; LOSS OF USE, DATA, OR PROFITS; OR BUSINESS
24 // INTERRUPTION) HOWEVER CAUSED AND ON ANY THEORY OF LIABILITY, WHETHER
25 // IN CONTRACT, STRICT LIABILITY, OR TORT (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE OR
26 // OTHERWISE) ARISING IN ANY WAY OUT OF THE USE OF THIS SOFTWARE, EVEN
27 // IF ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGE.
28 //
29
30 extern "C" {
31 #include <sys/time.h>
32 }
33
34 #include <cctype>
35 #include <cstdlib>
36 #include <fstream>
37 #include <iomanip>
38 #include <iostream>
39 #include <memory>
40 #include <sstream>
41 #include <utility>
42 #include <vector>
43
44 #include "application.hpp"
45 #include "fs.hpp"
46 #include "reader.hpp"
47 #include "text.hpp"
48 #include "ui.hpp"
49
50 typedef std::unique_ptr< std::ostream > ostream_ptr;
51
52 static ostream_ptr
open_outfile(const tools::fs::path & path)53 open_outfile(const tools::fs::path& path)
54 {
55 ostream_ptr osp;
56 if (path.str() == "-")
57 osp = ostream_ptr(new std::ofstream("/dev/stdout"));
58 else
59 osp = ostream_ptr(new std::ofstream(path.c_str()));
60 if (!(*osp))
61 throw std::runtime_error("Could not create file " + path.str());
62 return osp;
63 }
64
65 static std::string
format_tv(struct timeval * tv)66 format_tv(struct timeval* tv)
67 {
68 std::ostringstream output;
69 output << static_cast< long >(tv->tv_sec) << '.'
70 << std::setfill('0') << std::setw(6)
71 << static_cast< long >(tv->tv_usec);
72 return output.str();
73 }
74
75 // ------------------------------------------------------------------------
76 // The "writer" interface.
77 // ------------------------------------------------------------------------
78
79 //!
80 //! \brief A base class that defines an output format.
81 //!
82 //! The writer base class defines a generic interface to output formats.
83 //! This is meant to be subclassed, and each subclass can redefine any
84 //! method to format the information as it wishes.
85 //!
86 //! This class is not tied to a output stream nor a file because, depending
87 //! on the output format, we will want to write to a single file or to
88 //! multiple ones.
89 //!
90 class writer {
91 public:
writer(void)92 writer(void) {}
~writer(void)93 virtual ~writer(void) {}
94
write_info(const std::string &,const std::string &)95 virtual void write_info(const std::string&, const std::string&) {}
write_ntps(size_t)96 virtual void write_ntps(size_t) {}
write_tp_start(const std::string &,size_t)97 virtual void write_tp_start(const std::string&, size_t) {}
write_tp_end(struct timeval *,const std::string &)98 virtual void write_tp_end(struct timeval*, const std::string&) {}
write_tc_start(const std::string &)99 virtual void write_tc_start(const std::string&) {}
write_tc_stdout_line(const std::string &)100 virtual void write_tc_stdout_line(const std::string&) {}
write_tc_stderr_line(const std::string &)101 virtual void write_tc_stderr_line(const std::string&) {}
write_tc_end(const std::string &,struct timeval *,const std::string &)102 virtual void write_tc_end(const std::string&, struct timeval*,
103 const std::string&) {}
write_eof(void)104 virtual void write_eof(void) {}
105 };
106
107 // ------------------------------------------------------------------------
108 // The "csv_writer" class.
109 // ------------------------------------------------------------------------
110
111 //!
112 //! \brief A very simple plain-text output format.
113 //!
114 //! The csv_writer class implements a very simple plain-text output
115 //! format that summarizes the results of each executed test case. The
116 //! results are meant to be easily parseable by third-party tools, hence
117 //! they are formatted as a CSV file.
118 //!
119 class csv_writer : public writer {
120 ostream_ptr m_os;
121 bool m_failed;
122
123 std::string m_tpname;
124 std::string m_tcname;
125
126 public:
csv_writer(const tools::fs::path & p)127 csv_writer(const tools::fs::path& p) :
128 m_os(open_outfile(p))
129 {
130 }
131
132 virtual
133 void
write_tp_start(const std::string & name,size_t ntcs)134 write_tp_start(const std::string& name,
135 size_t ntcs __attribute__((__unused__)))
136 {
137 m_tpname = name;
138 m_failed = false;
139 }
140
141 virtual
142 void
write_tp_end(struct timeval * tv,const std::string & reason)143 write_tp_end(struct timeval* tv, const std::string& reason)
144 {
145 const std::string timestamp = format_tv(tv);
146
147 if (!reason.empty())
148 (*m_os) << "tp, " << timestamp << ", " << m_tpname << ", bogus, "
149 << reason << "\n";
150 else if (m_failed)
151 (*m_os) << "tp, " << timestamp << ", "<< m_tpname << ", failed\n";
152 else
153 (*m_os) << "tp, " << timestamp << ", "<< m_tpname << ", passed\n";
154 }
155
156 virtual
157 void
write_tc_start(const std::string & name)158 write_tc_start(const std::string& name)
159 {
160 m_tcname = name;
161 }
162
163 virtual
164 void
write_tc_end(const std::string & state,struct timeval * tv,const std::string & reason)165 write_tc_end(const std::string& state, struct timeval* tv,
166 const std::string& reason)
167 {
168 std::string str = m_tpname + ", " + m_tcname + ", " + state;
169 if (!reason.empty())
170 str += ", " + reason;
171 (*m_os) << "tc, " << format_tv(tv) << ", " << str << "\n";
172
173 if (state == "failed")
174 m_failed = true;
175 }
176 };
177
178 // ------------------------------------------------------------------------
179 // The "ticker_writer" class.
180 // ------------------------------------------------------------------------
181
182 //!
183 //! \brief A console-friendly output format.
184 //!
185 //! The ticker_writer class implements a formatter that is user-friendly
186 //! in the sense that it shows the execution of test cases in an easy to
187 //! read format. It is not meant to be parseable and its format can
188 //! freely change across releases.
189 //!
190 class ticker_writer : public writer {
191 ostream_ptr m_os;
192
193 size_t m_curtp, m_ntps;
194 size_t m_tcs_passed, m_tcs_failed, m_tcs_skipped, m_tcs_expected_failures;
195 std::string m_tcname, m_tpname;
196 std::vector< std::string > m_failed_tcs;
197 std::map< std::string, std::string > m_expected_failures_tcs;
198 std::vector< std::string > m_failed_tps;
199
200 void
write_info(const std::string & what,const std::string & val)201 write_info(const std::string& what, const std::string& val)
202 {
203 if (what == "tests.root") {
204 (*m_os) << "Tests root: " << val << "\n\n";
205 }
206 }
207
208 void
write_ntps(size_t ntps)209 write_ntps(size_t ntps)
210 {
211 m_curtp = 1;
212 m_tcs_passed = 0;
213 m_tcs_failed = 0;
214 m_tcs_skipped = 0;
215 m_tcs_expected_failures = 0;
216 m_ntps = ntps;
217 }
218
219 void
write_tp_start(const std::string & tp,size_t ntcs)220 write_tp_start(const std::string& tp, size_t ntcs)
221 {
222 using tools::text::to_string;
223 using tools::ui::format_text;
224
225 m_tpname = tp;
226
227 (*m_os) << format_text(tp + " (" + to_string(m_curtp) +
228 "/" + to_string(m_ntps) + "): " +
229 to_string(ntcs) + " test cases")
230 << "\n";
231 (*m_os).flush();
232 }
233
234 void
write_tp_end(struct timeval * tv,const std::string & reason)235 write_tp_end(struct timeval* tv, const std::string& reason)
236 {
237 using tools::ui::format_text_with_tag;
238
239 m_curtp++;
240
241 if (!reason.empty()) {
242 (*m_os) << format_text_with_tag("BOGUS TEST PROGRAM: Cannot "
243 "trust its results because "
244 "of `" + reason + "'",
245 m_tpname + ": ", false)
246 << "\n";
247 m_failed_tps.push_back(m_tpname);
248 }
249 (*m_os) << "[" << format_tv(tv) << "s]\n\n";
250 (*m_os).flush();
251
252 m_tpname.clear();
253 }
254
255 void
write_tc_start(const std::string & tcname)256 write_tc_start(const std::string& tcname)
257 {
258 m_tcname = tcname;
259
260 (*m_os) << " " + tcname + ": ";
261 (*m_os).flush();
262 }
263
264 void
write_tc_end(const std::string & state,struct timeval * tv,const std::string & reason)265 write_tc_end(const std::string& state, struct timeval* tv,
266 const std::string& reason)
267 {
268 std::string str;
269
270 (*m_os) << "[" << format_tv(tv) << "s] ";
271
272 if (state == "expected_death" || state == "expected_exit" ||
273 state == "expected_failure" || state == "expected_signal" ||
274 state == "expected_timeout") {
275 str = "Expected failure: " + reason;
276 m_tcs_expected_failures++;
277 m_expected_failures_tcs[m_tpname + ":" + m_tcname] = reason;
278 } else if (state == "failed") {
279 str = "Failed: " + reason;
280 m_tcs_failed++;
281 m_failed_tcs.push_back(m_tpname + ":" + m_tcname);
282 } else if (state == "passed") {
283 str = "Passed.";
284 m_tcs_passed++;
285 } else if (state == "skipped") {
286 str = "Skipped: " + reason;
287 m_tcs_skipped++;
288 } else
289 std::abort();
290
291 // XXX Wrap text. format_text_with_tag does not currently allow
292 // to specify the current column, which is needed because we have
293 // already printed the tc's name.
294 (*m_os) << str << '\n';
295
296 m_tcname = "";
297 }
298
299 static void
write_expected_failures(const std::map<std::string,std::string> & xfails,std::ostream & os)300 write_expected_failures(const std::map< std::string, std::string >& xfails,
301 std::ostream& os)
302 {
303 using tools::ui::format_text;
304 using tools::ui::format_text_with_tag;
305
306 os << format_text("Test cases for known bugs:") << "\n";
307
308 for (std::map< std::string, std::string >::const_iterator iter =
309 xfails.begin(); iter != xfails.end(); iter++) {
310 const std::string& name = (*iter).first;
311 const std::string& reason = (*iter).second;
312
313 os << format_text_with_tag(reason, " " + name + ": ", false)
314 << "\n";
315 }
316 }
317
318 void
write_eof(void)319 write_eof(void)
320 {
321 using tools::text::join;
322 using tools::text::to_string;
323 using tools::ui::format_text;
324 using tools::ui::format_text_with_tag;
325
326 if (!m_failed_tps.empty()) {
327 (*m_os) << format_text("Failed (bogus) test programs:")
328 << "\n";
329 (*m_os) << format_text_with_tag(join(m_failed_tps, ", "),
330 " ", false) << "\n\n";
331 }
332
333 if (!m_expected_failures_tcs.empty()) {
334 write_expected_failures(m_expected_failures_tcs, *m_os);
335 (*m_os) << "\n";
336 }
337
338 if (!m_failed_tcs.empty()) {
339 (*m_os) << format_text("Failed test cases:") << "\n";
340 (*m_os) << format_text_with_tag(join(m_failed_tcs, ", "),
341 " ", false) << "\n\n";
342 }
343
344 (*m_os) << format_text("Summary for " + to_string(m_ntps) +
345 " test programs:") << "\n";
346 (*m_os) << format_text_with_tag(to_string(m_tcs_passed) +
347 " passed test cases.",
348 " ", false) << "\n";
349 (*m_os) << format_text_with_tag(to_string(m_tcs_failed) +
350 " failed test cases.",
351 " ", false) << "\n";
352 (*m_os) << format_text_with_tag(to_string(m_tcs_expected_failures) +
353 " expected failed test cases.",
354 " ", false) << "\n";
355 (*m_os) << format_text_with_tag(to_string(m_tcs_skipped) +
356 " skipped test cases.",
357 " ", false) << "\n";
358 }
359
360 public:
ticker_writer(const tools::fs::path & p)361 ticker_writer(const tools::fs::path& p) :
362 m_os(open_outfile(p))
363 {
364 }
365 };
366
367 // ------------------------------------------------------------------------
368 // The "xml" class.
369 // ------------------------------------------------------------------------
370
371 //!
372 //! \brief A single-file XML output format.
373 //!
374 //! The xml_writer class implements a formatter that prints the results
375 //! of test cases in an XML format easily parseable later on by other
376 //! utilities.
377 //!
378 class xml_writer : public writer {
379 ostream_ptr m_os;
380
381 std::string m_tcname, m_tpname;
382
383 static
384 std::string
attrval(const std::string & str)385 attrval(const std::string& str)
386 {
387 return str;
388 }
389
390 static
391 std::string
elemval(const std::string & str)392 elemval(const std::string& str)
393 {
394 std::ostringstream buf;
395 for (std::string::const_iterator iter = str.begin();
396 iter != str.end(); iter++) {
397 const int character = static_cast< unsigned char >(*iter);
398 if (character == '&') {
399 buf << "&";
400 } else if (character == '<') {
401 buf << "<";
402 } else if (character == '>') {
403 buf << ">";
404 } else if (std::isalnum(character) || std::ispunct(character) ||
405 std::isspace(character)) {
406 buf << static_cast< char >(character);
407 } else {
408 buf << "&#" << character << ";";
409 }
410 }
411 return buf.str();
412 }
413
414 void
write_info(const std::string & what,const std::string & val)415 write_info(const std::string& what, const std::string& val)
416 {
417 (*m_os) << "<info class=\"" << what << "\">" << val << "</info>\n";
418 }
419
420 void
write_tp_start(const std::string & tp,size_t ntcs)421 write_tp_start(const std::string& tp,
422 size_t ntcs __attribute__((__unused__)))
423 {
424 (*m_os) << "<tp id=\"" << attrval(tp) << "\">\n";
425 }
426
427 void
write_tp_end(struct timeval * tv,const std::string & reason)428 write_tp_end(struct timeval* tv, const std::string& reason)
429 {
430 if (!reason.empty())
431 (*m_os) << "<failed>" << elemval(reason) << "</failed>\n";
432 (*m_os) << "<tp-time>" << format_tv(tv) << "</tp-time>";
433 (*m_os) << "</tp>\n";
434 }
435
436 void
write_tc_start(const std::string & tcname)437 write_tc_start(const std::string& tcname)
438 {
439 (*m_os) << "<tc id=\"" << attrval(tcname) << "\">\n";
440 }
441
442 void
write_tc_stdout_line(const std::string & line)443 write_tc_stdout_line(const std::string& line)
444 {
445 (*m_os) << "<so>" << elemval(line) << "</so>\n";
446 }
447
448 void
write_tc_stderr_line(const std::string & line)449 write_tc_stderr_line(const std::string& line)
450 {
451 (*m_os) << "<se>" << elemval(line) << "</se>\n";
452 }
453
454 void
write_tc_end(const std::string & state,struct timeval * tv,const std::string & reason)455 write_tc_end(const std::string& state, struct timeval* tv,
456 const std::string& reason)
457 {
458 std::string str;
459
460 if (state == "expected_death" || state == "expected_exit" ||
461 state == "expected_failure" || state == "expected_signal" ||
462 state == "expected_timeout") {
463 (*m_os) << "<" << state << ">" << elemval(reason)
464 << "</" << state << ">\n";
465 } else if (state == "passed") {
466 (*m_os) << "<passed />\n";
467 } else if (state == "failed") {
468 (*m_os) << "<failed>" << elemval(reason) << "</failed>\n";
469 } else if (state == "skipped") {
470 (*m_os) << "<skipped>" << elemval(reason) << "</skipped>\n";
471 } else
472 std::abort();
473 (*m_os) << "<tc-time>" << format_tv(tv) << "</tc-time>";
474 (*m_os) << "</tc>\n";
475 }
476
477 void
write_eof(void)478 write_eof(void)
479 {
480 (*m_os) << "</tests-results>\n";
481 }
482
483 public:
xml_writer(const tools::fs::path & p)484 xml_writer(const tools::fs::path& p) :
485 m_os(open_outfile(p))
486 {
487 (*m_os) << "<?xml version=\"1.0\" encoding=\"ISO-8859-1\"?>\n"
488 << "<!DOCTYPE tests-results PUBLIC "
489 "\"-//NetBSD//DTD ATF Tests Results 0.1//EN\" "
490 "\"http://www.NetBSD.org/XML/atf/tests-results.dtd\">\n\n"
491 "<tests-results>\n";
492 }
493 };
494
495 // ------------------------------------------------------------------------
496 // The "converter" class.
497 // ------------------------------------------------------------------------
498
499 //!
500 //! \brief A reader that redirects events to multiple writers.
501 //!
502 //! The converter class implements an atf_tps_reader that, for each event
503 //! raised by the parser, redirects it to multiple writers so that they
504 //! can reformat it according to their output rules.
505 //!
506 class converter : public tools::atf_report::atf_tps_reader {
507 typedef std::vector< writer* > outs_vector;
508 outs_vector m_outs;
509
510 void
got_info(const std::string & what,const std::string & val)511 got_info(const std::string& what, const std::string& val)
512 {
513 for (outs_vector::iterator iter = m_outs.begin();
514 iter != m_outs.end(); iter++)
515 (*iter)->write_info(what, val);
516 }
517
518 void
got_ntps(size_t ntps)519 got_ntps(size_t ntps)
520 {
521 for (outs_vector::iterator iter = m_outs.begin();
522 iter != m_outs.end(); iter++)
523 (*iter)->write_ntps(ntps);
524 }
525
526 void
got_tp_start(const std::string & tp,size_t ntcs)527 got_tp_start(const std::string& tp, size_t ntcs)
528 {
529 for (outs_vector::iterator iter = m_outs.begin();
530 iter != m_outs.end(); iter++)
531 (*iter)->write_tp_start(tp, ntcs);
532 }
533
534 void
got_tp_end(struct timeval * tv,const std::string & reason)535 got_tp_end(struct timeval* tv, const std::string& reason)
536 {
537 for (outs_vector::iterator iter = m_outs.begin();
538 iter != m_outs.end(); iter++)
539 (*iter)->write_tp_end(tv, reason);
540 }
541
542 void
got_tc_start(const std::string & tcname)543 got_tc_start(const std::string& tcname)
544 {
545 for (outs_vector::iterator iter = m_outs.begin();
546 iter != m_outs.end(); iter++)
547 (*iter)->write_tc_start(tcname);
548 }
549
550 void
got_tc_stdout_line(const std::string & line)551 got_tc_stdout_line(const std::string& line)
552 {
553 for (outs_vector::iterator iter = m_outs.begin();
554 iter != m_outs.end(); iter++)
555 (*iter)->write_tc_stdout_line(line);
556 }
557
558 void
got_tc_stderr_line(const std::string & line)559 got_tc_stderr_line(const std::string& line)
560 {
561 for (outs_vector::iterator iter = m_outs.begin();
562 iter != m_outs.end(); iter++)
563 (*iter)->write_tc_stderr_line(line);
564 }
565
566 void
got_tc_end(const std::string & state,struct timeval * tv,const std::string & reason)567 got_tc_end(const std::string& state, struct timeval* tv,
568 const std::string& reason)
569 {
570 for (outs_vector::iterator iter = m_outs.begin();
571 iter != m_outs.end(); iter++)
572 (*iter)->write_tc_end(state, tv, reason);
573 }
574
575 void
got_eof(void)576 got_eof(void)
577 {
578 for (outs_vector::iterator iter = m_outs.begin();
579 iter != m_outs.end(); iter++)
580 (*iter)->write_eof();
581 }
582
583 public:
converter(std::istream & is)584 converter(std::istream& is) :
585 tools::atf_report::atf_tps_reader(is)
586 {
587 }
588
~converter(void)589 ~converter(void)
590 {
591 for (outs_vector::iterator iter = m_outs.begin();
592 iter != m_outs.end(); iter++)
593 delete *iter;
594 }
595
596 void
add_output(const std::string & fmt,const tools::fs::path & p)597 add_output(const std::string& fmt, const tools::fs::path& p)
598 {
599 if (fmt == "csv") {
600 m_outs.push_back(new csv_writer(p));
601 } else if (fmt == "ticker") {
602 m_outs.push_back(new ticker_writer(p));
603 } else if (fmt == "xml") {
604 m_outs.push_back(new xml_writer(p));
605 } else
606 throw std::runtime_error("Unknown format `" + fmt + "'");
607 }
608 };
609
610 // ------------------------------------------------------------------------
611 // The "atf_report" class.
612 // ------------------------------------------------------------------------
613
614 class atf_report : public tools::application::app {
615 static const char* m_description;
616
617 typedef std::pair< std::string, tools::fs::path > fmt_path_pair;
618 std::vector< fmt_path_pair > m_oflags;
619
620 void process_option(int, const char*);
621 options_set specific_options(void) const;
622
623 public:
624 atf_report(void);
625
626 int main(void);
627 };
628
629 const char* atf_report::m_description =
630 "atf-report is a tool that parses the output of atf-run and "
631 "generates user-friendly reports in multiple different formats.";
632
atf_report(void)633 atf_report::atf_report(void) :
634 app(m_description, "atf-report(1)", "atf(7)")
635 {
636 }
637
638 void
process_option(int ch,const char * arg)639 atf_report::process_option(int ch, const char* arg)
640 {
641 switch (ch) {
642 case 'o':
643 {
644 std::string str(arg);
645 std::string::size_type pos = str.find(':');
646 if (pos == std::string::npos)
647 throw std::runtime_error("Syntax error in -o option");
648 else {
649 std::string fmt = str.substr(0, pos);
650 tools::fs::path path = tools::fs::path(str.substr(pos + 1));
651 m_oflags.push_back(fmt_path_pair(fmt, path));
652 }
653 }
654 break;
655
656 default:
657 std::abort();
658 }
659 }
660
661 atf_report::options_set
specific_options(void) const662 atf_report::specific_options(void)
663 const
664 {
665 using tools::application::option;
666 options_set opts;
667 opts.insert(option('o', "fmt:path", "Adds a new output file; multiple "
668 "ones can be specified, and a - "
669 "path means stdout"));
670 return opts;
671 }
672
673 int
main(void)674 atf_report::main(void)
675 {
676 if (m_argc > 0)
677 throw std::runtime_error("No arguments allowed");
678
679 if (m_oflags.empty())
680 m_oflags.push_back(fmt_path_pair("ticker", tools::fs::path("-")));
681
682 // Look for path duplicates.
683 std::set< tools::fs::path > paths;
684 for (std::vector< fmt_path_pair >::const_iterator iter = m_oflags.begin();
685 iter != m_oflags.end(); iter++) {
686 tools::fs::path p = (*iter).second;
687 if (p == tools::fs::path("/dev/stdout"))
688 p = tools::fs::path("-");
689 if (paths.find(p) != paths.end())
690 throw std::runtime_error("The file `" + p.str() + "' was "
691 "specified more than once");
692 paths.insert((*iter).second);
693 }
694
695 // Generate the output files.
696 converter cnv(std::cin);
697 for (std::vector< fmt_path_pair >::const_iterator iter = m_oflags.begin();
698 iter != m_oflags.end(); iter++)
699 cnv.add_output((*iter).first, (*iter).second);
700 cnv.read();
701
702 return EXIT_SUCCESS;
703 }
704
705 int
main(int argc,char * const * argv)706 main(int argc, char* const* argv)
707 {
708 return atf_report().run(argc, argv);
709 }
710