1@c Copyright (C) 2002-2022 Free Software Foundation, Inc. 2@c This is part of the GCC manual. 3@c For copying conditions, see the file gcc.texi. 4 5@node Type Information 6@chapter Memory Management and Type Information 7@cindex GGC 8@findex GTY 9 10GCC uses some fairly sophisticated memory management techniques, which 11involve determining information about GCC's data structures from GCC's 12source code and using this information to perform garbage collection and 13implement precompiled headers. 14 15A full C++ parser would be too complicated for this task, so a limited 16subset of C++ is interpreted and special markers are used to determine 17what parts of the source to look at. All @code{struct}, @code{union} 18and @code{template} structure declarations that define data structures 19that are allocated under control of the garbage collector must be 20marked. All global variables that hold pointers to garbage-collected 21memory must also be marked. Finally, all global variables that need 22to be saved and restored by a precompiled header must be marked. (The 23precompiled header mechanism can only save static variables if they're 24scalar. Complex data structures must be allocated in garbage-collected 25memory to be saved in a precompiled header.) 26 27The full format of a marker is 28@smallexample 29GTY (([@var{option}] [(@var{param})], [@var{option}] [(@var{param})] @dots{})) 30@end smallexample 31@noindent 32but in most cases no options are needed. The outer double parentheses 33are still necessary, though: @code{GTY(())}. Markers can appear: 34 35@itemize @bullet 36@item 37In a structure definition, before the open brace; 38@item 39In a global variable declaration, after the keyword @code{static} or 40@code{extern}; and 41@item 42In a structure field definition, before the name of the field. 43@end itemize 44 45Here are some examples of marking simple data structures and globals. 46 47@smallexample 48struct GTY(()) @var{tag} 49@{ 50 @var{fields}@dots{} 51@}; 52 53typedef struct GTY(()) @var{tag} 54@{ 55 @var{fields}@dots{} 56@} *@var{typename}; 57 58static GTY(()) struct @var{tag} *@var{list}; /* @r{points to GC memory} */ 59static GTY(()) int @var{counter}; /* @r{save counter in a PCH} */ 60@end smallexample 61 62The parser understands simple typedefs such as 63@code{typedef struct @var{tag} *@var{name};} and 64@code{typedef int @var{name};}. 65These don't need to be marked. 66 67However, in combination with GTY, avoid using typedefs such as 68@code{typedef int_hash<@dots{}> @var{name};} 69for these generate infinite-recursion code. 70See @uref{https://gcc.gnu.org/PR103157,PR103157}. 71Instead, you may use 72@code{struct @var{name} : int_hash<@dots{}> @{@};}, 73for example. 74 75Since @code{gengtype}'s understanding of C++ is limited, there are 76several constructs and declarations that are not supported inside 77classes/structures marked for automatic GC code generation. The 78following C++ constructs produce a @code{gengtype} error on 79structures/classes marked for automatic GC code generation: 80 81@itemize @bullet 82@item 83Type definitions inside classes/structures are not supported. 84@item 85Enumerations inside classes/structures are not supported. 86@end itemize 87 88If you have a class or structure using any of the above constructs, 89you need to mark that class as @code{GTY ((user))} and provide your 90own marking routines (see section @ref{User GC} for details). 91 92It is always valid to include function definitions inside classes. 93Those are always ignored by @code{gengtype}, as it only cares about 94data members. 95 96@menu 97* GTY Options:: What goes inside a @code{GTY(())}. 98* Inheritance and GTY:: Adding GTY to a class hierarchy. 99* User GC:: Adding user-provided GC marking routines. 100* GGC Roots:: Making global variables GGC roots. 101* Files:: How the generated files work. 102* Invoking the garbage collector:: How to invoke the garbage collector. 103* Troubleshooting:: When something does not work as expected. 104@end menu 105 106@node GTY Options 107@section The Inside of a @code{GTY(())} 108 109Sometimes the C code is not enough to fully describe the type 110structure. Extra information can be provided with @code{GTY} options 111and additional markers. Some options take a parameter, which may be 112either a string or a type name, depending on the parameter. If an 113option takes no parameter, it is acceptable either to omit the 114parameter entirely, or to provide an empty string as a parameter. For 115example, @code{@w{GTY ((skip))}} and @code{@w{GTY ((skip ("")))}} are 116equivalent. 117 118When the parameter is a string, often it is a fragment of C code. Four 119special escapes may be used in these strings, to refer to pieces of 120the data structure being marked: 121 122@cindex % in GTY option 123@table @code 124@item %h 125The current structure. 126@item %1 127The structure that immediately contains the current structure. 128@item %0 129The outermost structure that contains the current structure. 130@item %a 131A partial expression of the form @code{[i1][i2]@dots{}} that indexes 132the array item currently being marked. 133@end table 134 135For instance, suppose that you have a structure of the form 136@smallexample 137struct A @{ 138 @dots{} 139@}; 140struct B @{ 141 struct A foo[12]; 142@}; 143@end smallexample 144@noindent 145and @code{b} is a variable of type @code{struct B}. When marking 146@samp{b.foo[11]}, @code{%h} would expand to @samp{b.foo[11]}, 147@code{%0} and @code{%1} would both expand to @samp{b}, and @code{%a} 148would expand to @samp{[11]}. 149 150As in ordinary C, adjacent strings will be concatenated; this is 151helpful when you have a complicated expression. 152@smallexample 153@group 154GTY ((chain_next ("TREE_CODE (&%h.generic) == INTEGER_TYPE" 155 " ? TYPE_NEXT_VARIANT (&%h.generic)" 156 " : TREE_CHAIN (&%h.generic)"))) 157@end group 158@end smallexample 159 160The available options are: 161 162@table @code 163@findex length 164@item length ("@var{expression}") 165 166There are two places the type machinery will need to be explicitly told 167the length of an array of non-atomic objects. The first case is when a 168structure ends in a variable-length array, like this: 169@smallexample 170struct GTY(()) rtvec_def @{ 171 int num_elem; /* @r{number of elements} */ 172 rtx GTY ((length ("%h.num_elem"))) elem[1]; 173@}; 174@end smallexample 175 176In this case, the @code{length} option is used to override the specified 177array length (which should usually be @code{1}). The parameter of the 178option is a fragment of C code that calculates the length. 179 180The second case is when a structure or a global variable contains a 181pointer to an array, like this: 182@smallexample 183struct gimple_omp_for_iter * GTY((length ("%h.collapse"))) iter; 184@end smallexample 185In this case, @code{iter} has been allocated by writing something like 186@smallexample 187 x->iter = ggc_alloc_cleared_vec_gimple_omp_for_iter (collapse); 188@end smallexample 189and the @code{collapse} provides the length of the field. 190 191This second use of @code{length} also works on global variables, like: 192@verbatim 193static GTY((length("reg_known_value_size"))) rtx *reg_known_value; 194@end verbatim 195 196Note that the @code{length} option is only meant for use with arrays of 197non-atomic objects, that is, objects that contain pointers pointing to 198other GTY-managed objects. For other GC-allocated arrays and strings 199you should use @code{atomic}. 200 201@findex skip 202@item skip 203 204If @code{skip} is applied to a field, the type machinery will ignore it. 205This is somewhat dangerous; the only safe use is in a union when one 206field really isn't ever used. 207 208@findex callback 209@item callback 210 211@code{callback} should be applied to fields with pointer to function type 212and causes the field to be ignored similarly to @code{skip}, except when 213writing PCH and the field is non-NULL it will remember the field's address 214for relocation purposes if the process writing PCH has different load base 215from a process reading PCH. 216 217@findex for_user 218@item for_user 219 220Use this to mark types that need to be marked by user gc routines, but are not 221refered to in a template argument. So if you have some user gc type T1 and a 222non user gc type T2 you can give T2 the for_user option so that the marking 223functions for T1 can call non mangled functions to mark T2. 224 225@findex desc 226@findex tag 227@findex default 228@item desc ("@var{expression}") 229@itemx tag ("@var{constant}") 230@itemx default 231 232The type machinery needs to be told which field of a @code{union} is 233currently active. This is done by giving each field a constant 234@code{tag} value, and then specifying a discriminator using @code{desc}. 235The value of the expression given by @code{desc} is compared against 236each @code{tag} value, each of which should be different. If no 237@code{tag} is matched, the field marked with @code{default} is used if 238there is one, otherwise no field in the union will be marked. 239 240In the @code{desc} option, the ``current structure'' is the union that 241it discriminates. Use @code{%1} to mean the structure containing it. 242There are no escapes available to the @code{tag} option, since it is a 243constant. 244 245For example, 246@smallexample 247struct GTY(()) tree_binding 248@{ 249 struct tree_common common; 250 union tree_binding_u @{ 251 tree GTY ((tag ("0"))) scope; 252 struct cp_binding_level * GTY ((tag ("1"))) level; 253 @} GTY ((desc ("BINDING_HAS_LEVEL_P ((tree)&%0)"))) xscope; 254 tree value; 255@}; 256@end smallexample 257 258In this example, the value of BINDING_HAS_LEVEL_P when applied to a 259@code{struct tree_binding *} is presumed to be 0 or 1. If 1, the type 260mechanism will treat the field @code{level} as being present and if 0, 261will treat the field @code{scope} as being present. 262 263The @code{desc} and @code{tag} options can also be used for inheritance 264to denote which subclass an instance is. See @ref{Inheritance and GTY} 265for more information. 266 267@findex cache 268@item cache 269 270When the @code{cache} option is applied to a global variable gt_cleare_cache is 271called on that variable between the mark and sweep phases of garbage 272collection. The gt_clear_cache function is free to mark blocks as used, or to 273clear pointers in the variable. 274 275@findex deletable 276@item deletable 277 278@code{deletable}, when applied to a global variable, indicates that when 279garbage collection runs, there's no need to mark anything pointed to 280by this variable, it can just be set to @code{NULL} instead. This is used 281to keep a list of free structures around for re-use. 282 283@findex maybe_undef 284@item maybe_undef 285 286When applied to a field, @code{maybe_undef} indicates that it's OK if 287the structure that this fields points to is never defined, so long as 288this field is always @code{NULL}. This is used to avoid requiring 289backends to define certain optional structures. It doesn't work with 290language frontends. 291 292@findex nested_ptr 293@item nested_ptr (@var{type}, "@var{to expression}", "@var{from expression}") 294 295The type machinery expects all pointers to point to the start of an 296object. Sometimes for abstraction purposes it's convenient to have 297a pointer which points inside an object. So long as it's possible to 298convert the original object to and from the pointer, such pointers 299can still be used. @var{type} is the type of the original object, 300the @var{to expression} returns the pointer given the original object, 301and the @var{from expression} returns the original object given 302the pointer. The pointer will be available using the @code{%h} 303escape. 304 305@findex chain_next 306@findex chain_prev 307@findex chain_circular 308@item chain_next ("@var{expression}") 309@itemx chain_prev ("@var{expression}") 310@itemx chain_circular ("@var{expression}") 311 312It's helpful for the type machinery to know if objects are often 313chained together in long lists; this lets it generate code that uses 314less stack space by iterating along the list instead of recursing down 315it. @code{chain_next} is an expression for the next item in the list, 316@code{chain_prev} is an expression for the previous item. For singly 317linked lists, use only @code{chain_next}; for doubly linked lists, use 318both. The machinery requires that taking the next item of the 319previous item gives the original item. @code{chain_circular} is similar 320to @code{chain_next}, but can be used for circular single linked lists. 321 322@findex reorder 323@item reorder ("@var{function name}") 324 325Some data structures depend on the relative ordering of pointers. If 326the precompiled header machinery needs to change that ordering, it 327will call the function referenced by the @code{reorder} option, before 328changing the pointers in the object that's pointed to by the field the 329option applies to. The function must take four arguments, with the 330signature @samp{@w{void *, void *, gt_pointer_operator, void *}}. 331The first parameter is a pointer to the structure that contains the 332object being updated, or the object itself if there is no containing 333structure. The second parameter is a cookie that should be ignored. 334The third parameter is a routine that, given a pointer, will update it 335to its correct new value. The fourth parameter is a cookie that must 336be passed to the second parameter. 337 338PCH cannot handle data structures that depend on the absolute values 339of pointers. @code{reorder} functions can be expensive. When 340possible, it is better to depend on properties of the data, like an ID 341number or the hash of a string instead. 342 343@findex atomic 344@item atomic 345 346The @code{atomic} option can only be used with pointers. It informs 347the GC machinery that the memory that the pointer points to does not 348contain any pointers, and hence it should be treated by the GC and PCH 349machinery as an ``atomic'' block of memory that does not need to be 350examined when scanning memory for pointers. In particular, the 351machinery will not scan that memory for pointers to mark them as 352reachable (when marking pointers for GC) or to relocate them (when 353writing a PCH file). 354 355The @code{atomic} option differs from the @code{skip} option. 356@code{atomic} keeps the memory under Garbage Collection, but makes the 357GC ignore the contents of the memory. @code{skip} is more drastic in 358that it causes the pointer and the memory to be completely ignored by 359the Garbage Collector. So, memory marked as @code{atomic} is 360automatically freed when no longer reachable, while memory marked as 361@code{skip} is not. 362 363The @code{atomic} option must be used with great care, because all 364sorts of problem can occur if used incorrectly, that is, if the memory 365the pointer points to does actually contain a pointer. 366 367Here is an example of how to use it: 368@smallexample 369struct GTY(()) my_struct @{ 370 int number_of_elements; 371 unsigned int * GTY ((atomic)) elements; 372@}; 373@end smallexample 374In this case, @code{elements} is a pointer under GC, and the memory it 375points to needs to be allocated using the Garbage Collector, and will 376be freed automatically by the Garbage Collector when it is no longer 377referenced. But the memory that the pointer points to is an array of 378@code{unsigned int} elements, and the GC must not try to scan it to 379find pointers to mark or relocate, which is why it is marked with the 380@code{atomic} option. 381 382Note that, currently, global variables cannot be marked with 383@code{atomic}; only fields of a struct can. This is a known 384limitation. It would be useful to be able to mark global pointers 385with @code{atomic} to make the PCH machinery aware of them so that 386they are saved and restored correctly to PCH files. 387 388@findex special 389@item special ("@var{name}") 390 391The @code{special} option is used to mark types that have to be dealt 392with by special case machinery. The parameter is the name of the 393special case. See @file{gengtype.cc} for further details. Avoid 394adding new special cases unless there is no other alternative. 395 396@findex user 397@item user 398 399The @code{user} option indicates that the code to mark structure 400fields is completely handled by user-provided routines. See section 401@ref{User GC} for details on what functions need to be provided. 402@end table 403 404@node Inheritance and GTY 405@section Support for inheritance 406gengtype has some support for simple class hierarchies. You can use 407this to have gengtype autogenerate marking routines, provided: 408 409@itemize @bullet 410@item 411There must be a concrete base class, with a discriminator expression 412that can be used to identify which subclass an instance is. 413@item 414Only single inheritance is used. 415@item 416None of the classes within the hierarchy are templates. 417@end itemize 418 419If your class hierarchy does not fit in this pattern, you must use 420@ref{User GC} instead. 421 422The base class and its discriminator must be identified using the ``desc'' 423option. Each concrete subclass must use the ``tag'' option to identify 424which value of the discriminator it corresponds to. 425 426Every class in the hierarchy must have a @code{GTY(())} marker, as 427gengtype will only attempt to parse classes that have such a marker 428@footnote{Classes lacking such a marker will not be identified as being 429part of the hierarchy, and so the marking routines will not handle them, 430leading to a assertion failure within the marking routines due to an 431unknown tag value (assuming that assertions are enabled).}. 432 433@smallexample 434class GTY((desc("%h.kind"), tag("0"))) example_base 435@{ 436public: 437 int kind; 438 tree a; 439@}; 440 441class GTY((tag("1"))) some_subclass : public example_base 442@{ 443public: 444 tree b; 445@}; 446 447class GTY((tag("2"))) some_other_subclass : public example_base 448@{ 449public: 450 tree c; 451@}; 452@end smallexample 453 454The generated marking routines for the above will contain a ``switch'' 455on ``kind'', visiting all appropriate fields. For example, if kind is 4562, it will cast to ``some_other_subclass'' and visit fields a, b, and c. 457 458@node User GC 459@section Support for user-provided GC marking routines 460@cindex user gc 461The garbage collector supports types for which no automatic marking 462code is generated. For these types, the user is required to provide 463three functions: one to act as a marker for garbage collection, and 464two functions to act as marker and pointer walker for pre-compiled 465headers. 466 467Given a structure @code{struct GTY((user)) my_struct}, the following functions 468should be defined to mark @code{my_struct}: 469 470@smallexample 471void gt_ggc_mx (my_struct *p) 472@{ 473 /* This marks field 'fld'. */ 474 gt_ggc_mx (p->fld); 475@} 476 477void gt_pch_nx (my_struct *p) 478@{ 479 /* This marks field 'fld'. */ 480 gt_pch_nx (tp->fld); 481@} 482 483void gt_pch_nx (my_struct *p, gt_pointer_operator op, void *cookie) 484@{ 485 /* For every field 'fld', call the given pointer operator. */ 486 op (&(tp->fld), NULL, cookie); 487@} 488@end smallexample 489 490In general, each marker @code{M} should call @code{M} for every 491pointer field in the structure. Fields that are not allocated in GC 492or are not pointers must be ignored. 493 494For embedded lists (e.g., structures with a @code{next} or @code{prev} 495pointer), the marker must follow the chain and mark every element in 496it. 497 498Note that the rules for the pointer walker @code{gt_pch_nx (my_struct 499*, gt_pointer_operator, void *)} are slightly different. In this 500case, the operation @code{op} must be applied to the @emph{address} of 501every pointer field. 502 503@subsection User-provided marking routines for template types 504When a template type @code{TP} is marked with @code{GTY}, all 505instances of that type are considered user-provided types. This means 506that the individual instances of @code{TP} do not need to be marked 507with @code{GTY}. The user needs to provide template functions to mark 508all the fields of the type. 509 510The following code snippets represent all the functions that need to 511be provided. Note that type @code{TP} may reference to more than one 512type. In these snippets, there is only one type @code{T}, but there 513could be more. 514 515@smallexample 516template<typename T> 517void gt_ggc_mx (TP<T> *tp) 518@{ 519 extern void gt_ggc_mx (T&); 520 521 /* This marks field 'fld' of type 'T'. */ 522 gt_ggc_mx (tp->fld); 523@} 524 525template<typename T> 526void gt_pch_nx (TP<T> *tp) 527@{ 528 extern void gt_pch_nx (T&); 529 530 /* This marks field 'fld' of type 'T'. */ 531 gt_pch_nx (tp->fld); 532@} 533 534template<typename T> 535void gt_pch_nx (TP<T *> *tp, gt_pointer_operator op, void *cookie) 536@{ 537 /* For every field 'fld' of 'tp' with type 'T *', call the given 538 pointer operator. */ 539 op (&(tp->fld), NULL, cookie); 540@} 541 542template<typename T> 543void gt_pch_nx (TP<T> *tp, gt_pointer_operator, void *cookie) 544@{ 545 extern void gt_pch_nx (T *, gt_pointer_operator, void *); 546 547 /* For every field 'fld' of 'tp' with type 'T', call the pointer 548 walker for all the fields of T. */ 549 gt_pch_nx (&(tp->fld), op, cookie); 550@} 551@end smallexample 552 553Support for user-defined types is currently limited. The following 554restrictions apply: 555 556@enumerate 557@item Type @code{TP} and all the argument types @code{T} must be 558marked with @code{GTY}. 559 560@item Type @code{TP} can only have type names in its argument list. 561 562@item The pointer walker functions are different for @code{TP<T>} and 563@code{TP<T *>}. In the case of @code{TP<T>}, references to 564@code{T} must be handled by calling @code{gt_pch_nx} (which 565will, in turn, walk all the pointers inside fields of @code{T}). 566In the case of @code{TP<T *>}, references to @code{T *} must be 567handled by calling the @code{op} function on the address of the 568pointer (see the code snippets above). 569@end enumerate 570 571@node GGC Roots 572@section Marking Roots for the Garbage Collector 573@cindex roots, marking 574@cindex marking roots 575 576In addition to keeping track of types, the type machinery also locates 577the global variables (@dfn{roots}) that the garbage collector starts 578at. Roots must be declared using one of the following syntaxes: 579 580@itemize @bullet 581@item 582@code{extern GTY(([@var{options}])) @var{type} @var{name};} 583@item 584@code{static GTY(([@var{options}])) @var{type} @var{name};} 585@end itemize 586@noindent 587The syntax 588@itemize @bullet 589@item 590@code{GTY(([@var{options}])) @var{type} @var{name};} 591@end itemize 592@noindent 593is @emph{not} accepted. There should be an @code{extern} declaration 594of such a variable in a header somewhere---mark that, not the 595definition. Or, if the variable is only used in one file, make it 596@code{static}. 597 598@node Files 599@section Source Files Containing Type Information 600@cindex generated files 601@cindex files, generated 602 603Whenever you add @code{GTY} markers to a source file that previously 604had none, or create a new source file containing @code{GTY} markers, 605there are three things you need to do: 606 607@enumerate 608@item 609You need to add the file to the list of source files the type 610machinery scans. There are four cases: 611 612@enumerate a 613@item 614For a back-end file, this is usually done 615automatically; if not, you should add it to @code{target_gtfiles} in 616the appropriate port's entries in @file{config.gcc}. 617 618@item 619For files shared by all front ends, add the filename to the 620@code{GTFILES} variable in @file{Makefile.in}. 621 622@item 623For files that are part of one front end, add the filename to the 624@code{gtfiles} variable defined in the appropriate 625@file{config-lang.in}. 626Headers should appear before non-headers in this list. 627 628@item 629For files that are part of some but not all front ends, add the 630filename to the @code{gtfiles} variable of @emph{all} the front ends 631that use it. 632@end enumerate 633 634@item 635If the file was a header file, you'll need to check that it's included 636in the right place to be visible to the generated files. For a back-end 637header file, this should be done automatically. For a front-end header 638file, it needs to be included by the same file that includes 639@file{gtype-@var{lang}.h}. For other header files, it needs to be 640included in @file{gtype-desc.cc}, which is a generated file, so add it to 641@code{ifiles} in @code{open_base_file} in @file{gengtype.cc}. 642 643For source files that aren't header files, the machinery will generate a 644header file that should be included in the source file you just changed. 645The file will be called @file{gt-@var{path}.h} where @var{path} is the 646pathname relative to the @file{gcc} directory with slashes replaced by 647@verb{|-|}, so for example the header file to be included in 648@file{cp/parser.cc} is called @file{gt-cp-parser.h}. The 649generated header file should be included after everything else in the 650source file. 651 652@end enumerate 653 654For language frontends, there is another file that needs to be included 655somewhere. It will be called @file{gtype-@var{lang}.h}, where 656@var{lang} is the name of the subdirectory the language is contained in. 657 658Plugins can add additional root tables. Run the @code{gengtype} 659utility in plugin mode as @code{gengtype -P pluginout.h @var{source-dir} 660@var{file-list} @var{plugin*.c}} with your plugin files 661@var{plugin*.c} using @code{GTY} to generate the @var{pluginout.h} file. 662The GCC build tree is needed to be present in that mode. 663 664 665@node Invoking the garbage collector 666@section How to invoke the garbage collector 667@cindex garbage collector, invocation 668@findex ggc_collect 669 670The GCC garbage collector GGC is only invoked explicitly. In contrast 671with many other garbage collectors, it is not implicitly invoked by 672allocation routines when a lot of memory has been consumed. So the 673only way to have GGC reclaim storage is to call the @code{ggc_collect} 674function explicitly. 675With @var{mode} @code{GGC_COLLECT_FORCE} or otherwise (default 676@code{GGC_COLLECT_HEURISTIC}) when the internal heuristic decides to 677collect, this call is potentially an expensive operation, as it may 678have to scan the entire heap. Beware that local variables (on the GCC 679call stack) are not followed by such an invocation (as many other 680garbage collectors do): you should reference all your data from static 681or external @code{GTY}-ed variables, and it is advised to call 682@code{ggc_collect} with a shallow call stack. The GGC is an exact mark 683and sweep garbage collector (so it does not scan the call stack for 684pointers). In practice GCC passes don't often call @code{ggc_collect} 685themselves, because it is called by the pass manager between passes. 686 687At the time of the @code{ggc_collect} call all pointers in the GC-marked 688structures must be valid or @code{NULL}. In practice this means that 689there should not be uninitialized pointer fields in the structures even 690if your code never reads or writes those fields at a particular 691instance. One way to ensure this is to use cleared versions of 692allocators unless all the fields are initialized manually immediately 693after allocation. 694 695@node Troubleshooting 696@section Troubleshooting the garbage collector 697@cindex garbage collector, troubleshooting 698 699With the current garbage collector implementation, most issues should 700show up as GCC compilation errors. Some of the most commonly 701encountered issues are described below. 702 703@itemize @bullet 704@item Gengtype does not produce allocators for a @code{GTY}-marked type. 705Gengtype checks if there is at least one possible path from GC roots to 706at least one instance of each type before outputting allocators. If 707there is no such path, the @code{GTY} markers will be ignored and no 708allocators will be output. Solve this by making sure that there exists 709at least one such path. If creating it is unfeasible or raises a ``code 710smell'', consider if you really must use GC for allocating such type. 711 712@item Link-time errors about undefined @code{gt_ggc_r_foo_bar} and 713similarly-named symbols. Check if your @file{foo_bar} source file has 714@code{#include "gt-foo_bar.h"} as its very last line. 715 716@end itemize 717